Mohammad Hossein Eftekhari, Alireza Parsapour, Ayat Ahmadi, Bagher Larijani, Neda Yavari, Ehsan Shamsi Gooshki,
Volume 16, Issue 0 (11-2023)
Abstract
Defensive medicine is performing actions that have no medical indication and benefit for the patient (positive defensive medicine) or refraining from performing risky actions that have a medical indication and benefit for the patient (negative defensive medicine). These actions are carried out by the physicians with the sole motive of protecting themselves against complaints or tensions such as the protest of the patient or colleagues and usually cause physical, psychological, or economic harm to the patient or the institution that pays the treatment fee, such as insurance organizations. It can have consequences in terms of the quality of care and the efficient use of limited health resources. Factors such as the physician’s concerns about lawsuits and proceedings may lead to defensive behaviors. This study presented suggestions for the management and prevention of such behaviors, including three main categories related to the strategies for the reformation of the patient complaint handling system, social strategies for the management and prevention of defensive medicine, and managerial-organizational strategies. These strategies are based on the findings of a mixed-methods research including an unsystematic review of resources and a qualitative study conducted using semi-structured interviews. The results have been discussed by the Medical Ethics Committee of the Academy of Medical Sciences of Iran.
Ehsan Shamsi Gooshki,
Volume 17, Issue 1 (3-2024)
Abstract
Defensive medicine refers to actions taken by doctors and other medical professionals to protect themselves against potential threats and risks, particularly to prevent patient complaints or convictions in court, which is carried out in various forms including positive and negative defensive medicine. Since the primary motivation behind such actions, often viewed as morally unjustified, is to avoid legal proceedings and lawsuits, court rulings against doctors can intensify these behaviors. Reports of criminal sentences against some doctors in Iran and reactions from professional associations highlight the significance of this issue. This study examined the effects of such sentences on the healthcare system by referring to available documents and data on the widespread prevalence of defensive medicine in Iran, offering some suggestions for managing the issue. The objective of the study was to emphasize the importance of acknowledging the defensive motivations of doctors in healthcare and its influential factors, particularly the fear of criminal convictions, which can increase defensive behaviors among doctors and amplify their negative impacts on the healthcare system.
